The starting point, then, has to be whether the subject's life story is interesting as a standalone thing. And I think it's fair to say that in Terry Pratchett's case, that it was quite interesting. Not in any outstanding way - his wasn't an extraordinary life by any means - but there is no doubt that some of the aspects of his personality that come through in his writing also came through in the quirks of the way he went about life in general, especially in his social life and jobs before he became a full-time writer.
As a piece of writing, the biography does have some flaws. It's far too long. I got about half way through the more than 400 pages and started flagging, finishing it off much more slowly than the first half, because I had to force myself to go back for more, rather than returning to it eagerly. Rob Wilkins, who was Pratchett's assistant for a good number of years knew him well, had access to Pratchett's fragmentary autobiography and was probably uniquely well placed to put together this book. He writes well, though when he attempts humour it feels like he is trying too hard and can be a little wince-making. But the positives weren't enough to make the length enjoyable.
The other issue with the second half, other than it took me so long to get there, was that with success, inevitably, Pratchett's life becomes more detached from everyday experience than in his struggling years, and as such was harder to relate to.
I'm giving the book four stars because I think Wilkins does a good job, and in parts it is genuinely interesting - but it hasn't persuaded me of the benefit to a fan like me of reading a biography of the author. What I'll always treasure is Pratchett's novels. I'm quite happy to leave an author's life to the individual and their family.
See all of Brian's online articles or subscribe to a weekly digest for free here
I find this review rather astonishing in its dismissal of the second part of the biography, which is also the tale of Terry Pratchett’s struggle & decline due to an Embuggerance (early onset Alzheimer’s). For me, this was the most wrenching & rewarding read: how Terry Pratchett fought with/accommodated & suffered from his terminal illness. I personally found the description of his last years both poignant & heroically brave. Immense courage was required & shown by Pratchett & his colleagues, including the author, whom I consider related this time both vividly & sensitively.
ReplyDeleteI'm afraid I've never understood the appeal of what the publishing trade refers to as 'misery memoirs' or 'misery lit'. I don't find the description of other people's suffering entertaining or uplifting. I'd also say that if someone close to you is going through a similar experience this is not necessarily something you want to read about.
Delete